California retirement plan over promised and under performed
Jeff Patch:
School districts in wealthy areas sometimes make up for the pension obligations with direct donations to the schools, but poorer school districts do not have that option. The managers of the funds have also politicized the investment decisions which mean they are foregoing growth in investments for leftist political considerations.
The state salaries and the pensions for employees are more generous than any taxpayers can sustain over the long term. The result is they are shortchanging the taxpayers on services and schools.
The California Public Employee Retirement System, known as CalPERS, is in crisis. And it sure looks like things are going to get a whole lot worse before they can get a whole lot better.There is much more.
The system already has a $153 billion unfunded liability, one of the largest shortfalls of any state, and it only has funds to cover 68 percent of promised benefits into the future. And because CalPERS is already cash negative, paying out $5 billion more in benefits to retirees each year than it takes in, there aren’t many scenarios whereby the system would be able to make good on those promises absent outside intervention (read: taxpayer bailout).
Lawmakers and the fund’s board should be considering reforms to improve the system, but California voters and taxpayers faced another setback recently. Overseers of the pension plan—the nation’s largest—passed a funding plan earlier this year that projects shortfalls over the next decade but assumes rosy investment returns in coming decades to make up the difference. Given the high market valuations today, that assumption seems dubious.
When the CalPERS investment committee reallocated its investments recently, it assumed a 7 percent annualized rate of return. While CalPERS has enjoyed some good years—for example, its 2017 return may exceed 11 percent—that’s not the norm. The fund has averaged a 4.6 percent rate over the past decade, and its 2016 rate was an abysmal 0.6 percent.
CalPERS’ strategy -- and to a large extent that of the state in general -- seems crafted first and foremost to advance the interest of public sector labor unions. The high compensation for state government workers and the state’s munificent retirement benefits make it difficult for local government officials to find the money necessary to meet their obligations. Rising contribution rates for local governments mean that municipalities and schools have less money to educate children, build roads or provide other essential government functions.
CalPERS’s school district contribution rates to the pension plan are projected to skyrocket in the near future. The rates have risen to 15.5 percent from 11.8 percent in the 2015-2016 fiscal year, and are scheduled to reach 22.7 percent in 2020. School districts have little power to fight the increases, which are mandated at the state level. The only way to reduce pension contributions is to cut staff. Some layoffs may make sense for districts facing declining enrollment, but they can also harm educational outcomes.
...
School districts in wealthy areas sometimes make up for the pension obligations with direct donations to the schools, but poorer school districts do not have that option. The managers of the funds have also politicized the investment decisions which mean they are foregoing growth in investments for leftist political considerations.
The state salaries and the pensions for employees are more generous than any taxpayers can sustain over the long term. The result is they are shortchanging the taxpayers on services and schools.
Comments
Post a Comment