Posts

Showing posts with the label Military history

Does the military think it needs another civil war in the US?

 Helen Raleigh: Why Is The U.S. Military Fighting American Freedom Harder Than Foreign Threats?   Our military leaders should focus on fighting external threats at this crucial historical juncture, not fighting a domestic culture war. Corporate media and progressives found a new darling in Gen. Mark Milley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, after his congressional testimony last week. Anyone who dared to criticize him was blasted as either unpatriotic or demonstrating “white rage.” Republicans have criticized the U.S. military for promoting books that advocate for racial divisions — for example, listing Ibram Kendi’s critical race theory gospel, “How to Be an Antiracist,” as reading for sailors in the U.S. Navy. During his testimony, Milley made it clear he didn’t see anything wrong with training the U.S. military in critical race theory. Milley Defends Racist Indoctrination “I’ve read Mao Zedong. I’ve read Karl Marx. I’ve read Lenin,” he argued . “That doesn’t make m...

Democrats pushed to name bases after Confederate officers and miltary is taking another look at base names

Washington Post: Top military officer labels Confederacy as treasonous as Pentagon takes ‘hard look’ at rebel ties The Pentagon is exploring options to rename 10 Army installations that honor rebel leaders. As long as Democrats admit they were wrong to push these names, to begin with, I do not have a problem with renaming the bases after more illustrious figures.  There are several World War II generals who would be worthy of the honor.  The English probably thought the heroes of the American Revolution were treasonous.  That is the way of rebellions.  But the Democrats better be careful because the current rebellion they are sponsoring could get that label too.  Antifa and BLM could be considered for that label too.

How many troops at bases named after Confederate soldiers even knew who they were?

Washington Post: My experience at a Confederate-named Army base shows we need to rename them I am a student of history and have read a lot about the civil war and most of the men these bases are named after were not what I would call important figures other than Robert E. Lee.  It is hard to classify them as heroic.  If the names of the bases are changed, I would recommend naming them after consequential generals from World War I and II.  While some have suggested naming them after Medal of Honor recipients, I would stick with generals who made a difference.

Patton at the Battle of the Bulge

Investors.com: ... This was December 1944. The U.S. Army had figured it was close to turning out the lights on World War II in Europe. Hitler kept them flickering with a tank invasion of northwest Europe, in particular Belgium. In his scope: Antwerp's port, supplies, fuel and a peace pact to keep the American juggernaut from bagging Germany. The Battle of the Bulge was on. Gen. Dwight Eisenhower heard the alarm. Now he had to make the call. But to whom? George Patton. As soon as the three-star general had his marching orders, he made a beeline to the Bulge in Belgium — and in seven days rescued the trapped Americans in Bastogne while decking the Nazis. "It was Patton's finest hour," Harry Yeide wrote in "Fighting Patton." In Charge "There was not one other single man in the Army who could've done that," Mike Province, author of "The Unknown Patton" and head of the Patton Society, told IBD. "No one else had th...

Peace comes when the losing side determines it cause is hopeless

Spengler: Humiliation – the only path to peace for the Middle East President Trump's recognition of Jerusalem as the capital of the State of Israel will be as a stab in the heart to the Arab World. But anything else would be to succor Arab hopes that Israel might some day be defeated and eliminated One of the reasons Obama was such a spectacular failure as President was that he kept giving the losers hope and therefore extending the conflict beyond a time when it could have been resolved by demonstrating that their cause is hopeless. ... Wars end not when the loser is defeated, but rather when the loser is humiliated. Throughout history, as I argued in a 2016 survey of ancient and modern wars, losers have fought on until they lack the manpower to fill their depleted ranks. Typically that occurs after 30% of military-age men are dead, as in France during the Napoleonic Wars, the South in the American Civil War, or Germany in the Second World War. The losing side will not aba...

Mattis lives up to his reputation at hearings

Washington Examiner: Top 11 Mattis quotes from his Senate confirmation hearing Here are a few examples: 2. "History is not a straitjacket, but I've never found a better guide for the way ahead than studying the histories." 3. "There's another piece of wisdom from antiquity that says: fear, honor and interest always seem to be the root causes of why a nation chooses to go to hostilities." ... 6. "My belief is that we have to stay focused on the military that is so lethal that on the battlefield, it is the enemy's longest day and worst day when they run into that force." ... They are all worth your time. The statement about history is sorely needed as even higher education is deemphasizing the study of history.  It should be noted that the Europeans became dominant military powers when they began studying Greek and Roman warfare.

Why the US is not winning despite tactical superiority

Mark Moyer: The White House’s Seven Deadly Errors Moyer is a brilliant military historian who is not blinded by ideology.   He finds fault with the strategies used by both Bush and Obama.

Why liberals lose shooting wars

Caleb Howe: President Obama today made yet another statement that is sure to follow him for some time. There can be little doubt the President wanted this line to go down as part of his legacy. Just as there is small doubt that the opposition will pin it to him as a negative. Whatever the case, that the statement is completely false is without question, beyond any semblance of doubt. "Ideologies are not defeated with guns," the President said, "but better ideas and more attracting and more compelling vision." This is a lovely thought of the "I didn't put too much effort into this" variety. A simple rewording of the trite and bland 'violence is not the answer" trope, it is a message for kindergarten teachers to spiel yawningly to unruly youngsters. It is not an insight worthy of a serious adult, much less a world leader, and one that would elicit little more than a ho-hum from any but the most glassy-eyed of college freshmen were it delivere...

Gen. 'Mad Dog Mattis' on the importance of reading

Business Insider: ... The problem with being too busy to read is that you learn by experience (or by your men’s experience), i.e. the hard way. By reading, you learn through others’ experiences, generally a better way to do business, especially in our line of work where the consequences of incompetence are so final for young men.  Thanks to my reading, I have never been caught flat-footed by any situation, never at a loss for how any problem has been addressed (successfully or unsuccessfully) before. It doesn’t give me all the answers, but it lights what is often a dark path ahead.  With [Task Force] 58, I had w/ me Slim’s book, books about the Russian and British experiences in [Afghanistan], and a couple others. Going into Iraq, “The Siege” (about the Brits’ defeat at Al Kut in WW I) was req’d reading for field grade officers. I also had Slim’s book; reviewed T.E. Lawrence’s “Seven Pillars of Wisdom”; a good book about the life of Gertrude Bell (the Brit archaeologist...

Obama giving up naval supremacy

Gabriel Schoenfeld: Is naval power back? Early in June, Russia announced that it would be permanently stationing an armada of ships in the Mediterranean, restoring a deployment that came to an end with the dissolution of the Soviet Union. This muscle-flexing is part of Russia’s effort to bolster the government of Bashar al-Assad in Syria, and to stick a finger in the eye of the United States. China, for its part, recently introduced its first aircraft carrier, the Liaoning, and the formation of carrier battle groups will eventually follow, enabling the Chinese military to develop long-range capabilities at sea. As our major rivals expand their naval capabilities, America’s Navy has been on the way down. Today, the naval fleet is less than half the force it was at the end of the Cold War, and is roughly equivalent in size to what it was during World War I. And thanks to draconian cuts proposed by President Obama, the fleet will contract further in the decades to come. What does this m...

Muslim war against Christians sparked the Crusades

Dan McLaughlin: Let me put down here some facts that are worth returning to from time to time, as arguments over the history of Islam and Islamism are back in the news with today’s beheading in London. In debates over the history of tension between Muslims and Christians, the Crusades are often cited, out of their historical context, as the original cause of such clashes, as if both sides were peaceably minding their own business before imperialist Westerners decided to go launch a religious war in Muslim lands. This is not what actually happened , and indeed it is ahistorical to treat the fragmented feudal states of the West in the Eleventh Century as capable of any such thing as imperialism or colonialism (although, as Victor Davis Hanson has noted, even in the centuries after the fall of Rome, Western civilization retained a superior logistical ability to project force overseas due to the scientific, economic and military legacies of ancient Greece and Rome). Moreover, when Islam ...

Winston Churchill at 22 in Afghanistan

Con Coughlin: ... ...   he is less well disposed to the mullahs who incited the violence in the first place, and is appalled by their habit of trading their womenfolk to buy rifles. “This degradation of mind is unrelieved by a single elevated sentiment,” he writes. “Their religion is the most miserable fanaticism, in which cruelty, credulity, and immorality are equally represented. Their holy men – the Mullahs – prize as their chief privilege a sort of droit de seigneur. It is impossible to imagine a lower type of beings or a more dreadful state of barbarism.” ...  This is from Coughlin's book, Churchill's First War  about the fight with the Pashtun in Afghanistan in 1897. There does not appear to be much that has changed in Afghanistan since that fighting.

The history of raiding warfare

Max Boot: Pundits and the press too often treat terrorism and guerrilla tactics as something new, a departure from old-fashioned ways of war. But nothing could be further from the truth. Throughout most of our species' long and bloody slog, warfare has primarily been carried out by bands of loosely organized, ill-disciplined, and lightly armed volunteers who disdained open battle in favor of stealthy raids and ambushes: the strategies of both tribal warriors and modern guerrillas and terrorists. In fact, conventional warfare is the relatively recent invention. It was first made possible after 10,000 BC by the development of agricultural societies, which produced enough surplus wealth and population to allow for the creation of specially designed fortifications and weapons (and the professionals to operate them). The first genuine armies -- commanded by a strict hierarchy, composed of trained soldiers, disciplined with threats of punishment -- arose after 3100 BC in Egypt and Meso...

Civilian analysts who helped defeat al Qaeda

Washington Post: Frederick and Kimberly Kagan, a husband-and-wife team of hawkish military analysts, put their jobs at influential Washington think tanks on hold for almost a year to work for Gen. David H. Petraeus when he was the top U.S. commander in Afghanistan. Provided desks, e-mail accounts and top-level security clearances in Kabul, they pored through classified intelligence reports, participated in senior-level strategy sessions and probed the assessments of field officers in order to advise Petraeus about how to fight the war differently. Their compensation from the U.S. government for their efforts, which often involved 18-hour workdays, seven days a week and dangerous battlefield visits? Zero dollars. Although Fred Kagan said he and his wife wanted no pay in part to remain “completely independent,” the extraordinary arrangement raises new questions about the access and influence Petraeus accorded to civilian friends while he was running the Afghan war. ...  This is ...

Fun facts from the War of 1812

Patrick Hruby: The Revolutionary War has its own  national holiday . World War II has spawned countless books and movies. The Civil War boasts costumed re-enactors and a signature  chess  set. And the War of 1812? It has re-enactors, too. The country can’t get enough of them. The country of  Canada , that is. “The demand for them right now is so great that it’s actually driving up the price,” said  John Stagg , a  University of Virginia  history professor and author of “The War of 1812: Conflict for a Continent.” “They may even have to resort to the desperate tactic of importing a few from the United States. “The situation is different in  Canada . They take the war very seriously in a way that Americans don’t.” Currently enjoying its bicentennial — What, you haven’t pre-ordered the Postal Service ’s forthcoming commemorative stamp? — the War of 1812 occupies a musty, forgotten junk drawer in America’s collective cultural consciousness, ...

70 years after Midway, Democrats look to gut the Navy

Arthur Herman: On June 4, 1942, a battle off Midway Island marked the dawn of the United States Navy as the most powerful sea force in the world. Seventy years later, a civilian “battle” may doom its reach and power for good.   Then the enemy was imperial Japan. Today, it’s the administration and Congress, who seem unable or unwilling to stop defense cuts that will leave America vulnerable and the world more dangerous. We’re fast approaching the point where the US Navy can no longer guarantee the safety of the world’s sea lanes, on which our economic future depends. Seventy years ago, shorn of its battleships by the attack on Pearl Harbor, the Navy found itself on the defensive everywhere in the Pacific. And an overwhelming Japanese task force hoped to trap three of our fleet’s five surviving carriers — Hornet, Enterprise and Yorktown — off Midway and wipe out America as a naval competitor.  But a US observation plane spotted the Japanese first. Flying out with...

The Stolen Valor Act in the Supreme Court

Washington Post: The  Supreme Court  jousted for an hour Wednesday about whether the First Amendment allows the government to prosecute people for  lying about earning military honors , and, if so, what else might be fair game.  Lying about whether  your child  received a medal? wondered Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. Holocaust deniers? asked Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg.  People who lie about extramarital affairs? offered Justice Elena Kagan.  Justice Sonia Sotomayor tried out a personal example: “I take offense when someone I’m dating makes a claim that’s not true.”  At the end of the arguments in  U.S. v. Alvarez   , it was unclear how many of what  Solicitor General Donald V. Verrilli Jr . called the court’s “slippery slope” questions were in the form of genuine concern or simply playing devil’s advocate.  The questions raise difficult issues, Verrilli conceded, but should not keep the court from upholding the...

Leadership on the battlefield and beyond

Phillip Delves Broughton: After leading his men and elephants across the Alps, the Carthaginian general Hannibal was faced with a new problem: inspiring his forces to fight the Roman army. They had rushed across the frozen mountain passes to take the enemy, still in winter quarters, by surprise. But the insane exploit had a cost: The surviving forces were bedraggled and ill-fed. Besides, nearly half the elephants had died. Rather than launching into a motivational speech, Hannibal decided to put on a show, an ultimate fighting contest between the prisoners he had acquired in the mountains. He told these grizzled Gauls that a few would be chosen to fight each other. Whoever lost would, of course, die. But whoever won would be sent on his way, free and armed. The Gauls happily snatched up their weapons and beat the daylights out of each other. As they watched, the Carthaginians realized that they admired equally the victors and those who died honorably. Hannibal's point was ...

Behind the Obama Libya screw up

Image
Image by VinothChandar via Flickr David Wood: After 26 months in office, President Obama still has not forged a smoothly working national security team that can both nimbly pounce on military crises and deftly manage festering problems, say current and former U.S. officials. As in previous administrations, much of the problem lies in the friction between civilians working in the White House and military officers and Defense Department civilians working across the Potomac River in the Pentagon. Senior officials describe the predicament as a "culture clash." The miscommunications and misunderstandings between the groups cause frustration and anger, which sometimes even leads to policy paralysis, officials say. One recent example of this dynamic at work is the Obama administration's tentative, half-way intervention in the Libyan uprising. "It's a mess," lamented a senior U.S. official. Washington took the bold step of committing military force, but not...

Army to lose history center

Image
Cover via Amazon James Jay Carafano: It was known as a hard luck division -- until the day it got lucky. In Normandy, the 90th Division suffered more casualties than almost every other combat division. Two division commanders had already been relieved. Almost nothing seemed to go right. Until late July 1944. That's when the 90th got laced by German artillery fire ... and got very lucky indeed. None of the rounds exploded. Engineers inspecting the shells found they'd been loaded with sawdust. It was noted in the unit combat log -- and forgotten. Americans did not yet know that slave labor manufactured German munitions. Some deliberately sabotaged the ammunition bound for the front. They knew that, if discovered, their defiant acts would lead to torture and death. But these nameless, enslaved heroes did it anyway. The soldiers of the 90th never suspected they owed their lives to that anonymous courage. They just pressed on, fighting for freedom. At war's end, they l...