Were ESG and Big Green factors in bank failure?

 Kimberly Strassel:

If government funds it, they will come. That’s an overlooked story line in the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank. If Washington wants to point fingers, it should aim the biggest digit at itself.

Let’s talk about what actually imploded over the past week. If the name wasn’t already a giveaway, SVB was the lender of choice for tech dreamers. It claims to have banked nearly half of all U.S. venture-backed tech and healthcare startups. Yet in recent years those clients have skewed ever more in one direction. “We serve those creating positive environmental change,” SVB’s website brags, noting that the bank worked with some 1,550 companies in the “climate technology and sustainability sector.”
...

What inspires a bank to disregard risk and shower money on products or services that nobody is clamoring to buy? One answer is easy money and misguided regulation, which washed dollars into the economy even as it pushed banks like SVB to load up on sovereign debt, lulled by a Federal Reserve-fed belief that interest rates would stay near zero forever. The other? Washington handouts, via President Biden’s effort to engineer a climate industry that otherwise wouldn’t exist.
...

What inspires a bank to disregard risk and shower money on products or services that nobody is clamoring to buy? One answer is easy money and misguided regulation, which washed dollars into the economy even as it pushed banks like SVB to load up on sovereign debt, lulled by a Federal Reserve-fed belief that interest rates would stay near zero forever. The other? Washington handouts, via President Biden’s effort to engineer a climate industry that otherwise wouldn’t exist.

While the main reason SVB failed was its decision to buy bonds at the top of the market (it got hit when it had to sell), it had also in the past few years further stretched itself by sizably increasing its loans and lines of credit to subprime firms. How much of that would have happened if not for the Biden pot of gold at the end of the green-tech rainbow? A Washington Post story acknowledged that SVB’s weekend collapse initially meant that “many major clean tech companies faced insolvency.” It even accidentally admitted Washington’s role when it noted that many investors were nonetheless hopeful “the infusion of hundreds of billions of dollars in public money” from Washington legislation would “blunt the fallout from the bank collapse.”

The politics doesn’t end there. Even a junior banking regulator should have picked up on SVB’s distress, but that’s apparently a grade above San Francisco Federal Reserve President Mary Daly. She and her team have spent more time of late focused on hypothetical climate risk than the real risk of bank failures. What woke overseer wants to clamp down on the darling of clean-tech banking?

And as for that “infusion” of government dollars, it turns out investors don’t have to wait for grant bucks. SVB had relatively few depositors, but most exceeded the federal deposit-insurance limit of $250,000. Had this been a regional bank in Texas specializing in oil and natural-gas ventures, those depositors would surely be out of luck. But the Biden administration immediately swooped in with an SVB bailout, promising to make all those clean-tech companies whole. Subsidy money, a regulatory blind eye, and bailout bucks—talk about a favored industry. This, while most every other company in the country faces a bevy of hostile Biden regulators and lawsuits.
...

Democrats have a belief in Big Green that defies reality.  They have been wasting money on it since at least the Obama administration and Biden has been even more irresponsible in pushing Big Green.  How many times do these businesses have to fail to persuade Democrats to stop wasting taxpayer money on them? 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The myth of 'voter suppression'

Kerry's false premise on UN resolution