The 'living wage' fallacy
Diana Furchtgott Roth:
District of Columbia City Council members have approved "living wage" legislation that would require large retailers and their subcontractors to pay employees $12.50 an hour.This will only make it harder for young people to get experience they need in the workforce. Minimum wage jobs are a way of gaining that experience especially for people still living with their parents. With black youth unemployment still at record highs this just makes it tougher for them to get on the ladder to success. It is an example of how unions destroy jobs.
Mayor Vincent Gray should veto the Large Retailer Accountability Act of 2013, aimed at six new Wal-Mart stores, because it would hurt economic activity in the District and reduce employment and shopping opportunities for local residents.
Large retailers are defined as those with more than 75,000 square feet of space, and with parent company annual revenues of $1 billion or more. For now, this just applies to Wal-Mart stores planned for D.C. Other large stores, such as Target, Macy's and Home Depot, are grandfathered for four years, but would be affected later.
The District's unemployment rate in May was 8.5 percent, and it needs more jobs, not fewer.
The provisions of the bill "may be waived by the written terms of a bona fide collective bargaining agreement," so union shops would be exempt.
If Gray signs the bill, Wal-Mart said that it would not pursue three stores in Skyland, Capitol Gateway, and New York Avenue, some of the city's poorest areas.
Wal-Mart's suburban stores are routinely packed, with parking spaces hard to find, generating jobs and tax revenues for Maryland and Virginia.
Criticizing the bill, a Gray spokesman said, "The Mayor has already indicated his serious concerns over the lost jobs and retail opportunities for District residents that the bill will cause."
The bill justifies the living wage on the grounds that "retailers that pay living wages and provide affordable health benefits face growing pressure to cut back when their competitors are permitted to pay low wages and offer no benefits."
But how about small stores that pay low wages and no benefits? Or the D.C. government, which pays some people below $12.50 an hour? If the D.C. Council were truly concerned about the poor, why not mandate that all stores pay a living wage?
The bill is motivated not by care for low-income D.C. residents but by animus towards Wal-Mart, particularly from unions.
...
Comments
Post a Comment