Pakistan says Afgan's releasing Taliban they capture

Sara Carter:

Afghanistan has been releasing Taliban fighters captured in Pakistan and turned over to the Karzai government, creating a growing rift between the neighbors as they struggle to defeat insurgents, three senior Pakistani officials said.

The releases have made Pakistan reluctant to turn over some top Taliban captives, the officials said. The Afghanistan Embassy declined to comment on the allegation.

The Washington Examiner reviewed classified Pakistani military case summaries on roughly 1,100 captured or killed Taliban insurgents and suspected al Qaeda fighters.

The reports detailed the return to Afghanistan upon the request of the Karzai government of dozens of insurgents. However, upon their return, the classified documents noted that they were "released back to the Taliban as bargaining chips in negotiations."

A typical report detailed the case of a suspected Taliban named Maulvi Saeed. He was "a member [of] Taliban Shura in Kunar, planner of suicide bombings," the classified report said.

"Arrested on February 22, 2007, from Peshawar. Handed over to [National Directorate of Security] on 24, December, 2007. He was released by Afghan security officials without notifying Pakistan," a note attached to Saeed's report stated.

"They don't keep us on board and continually release dangerous and sometime high-level Taliban that we have captured," said a senior Pakistani official, who spoke on condition that he not be named.

...

Pentagon spokesman Lt. Col. Mark Wright said the United States is aware of the release of some detainees in Afghanistan but that U.S. and NATO partners "carefully monitor the situation."

One U.S. official with knowledge of detainee releases said American forces in the region "won't turn a blind eye after the detainees are let go."

The U.S. official said some suspected insurgents captured by American troops have also been released by the Afghan government, but he wouldn't second-guess the motives of the Afghans. "What can we do when there is no evidence or if the Afghan government makes the decision to release them once they're turned over? Our hands are tied," he said.

...

The Afghan catch and release program is not very smart. The Marines ran into the problem in Marjah where the captured Taliban could only be held for four days and then must automatically be released even though they were caught making war against us. It makes even less sense when dealing with high value targets that were captured in Pakistan sanctuaries. I don't blame the Pakistanis for being reluctant to turn over recently captured Taliban leaders.