Why big Green is losing
Joel Kotkin:
They are losing the debate because they have refused to engage skeptics and have instead engaged in name calling such as "denier." If Big Green has become a religion it has also become a doomsday cult pushing a "the end is near" rationale for adopting crushing regulations. It is looking more and more like an excuse for a despotic control freak government.
When President Trump pulled out of the Paris climate accords, embraced coal, and stacked his administration from people from fossil-fuel producing states, the environmental movement reacted with near-apocalyptic fear and fury. They would have been better off beginning to understand precisely why the country has become so indifferent to their cause, as evidenced by the victory not only of Trump but of unsympathetic Republicans at every level of government.There is more.
Yet there’s been little soul-searching among green activists and donors, or in the generally pliant media since November about how decades of exaggerated concerns—about peak oil, the “population bomb,” and even, a few decades back, global cooling—and demands for economic, social, and political sacrifices from the masses have damaged their movement.
Not long ago, many greens still embraced pragmatic solutions—for example substituting abundant natural gas for coal—that have generated large reductions in greenhouse gas emissions. Rather than celebrate those demonstrable successes, many environmentalists began pushing for a total ban on the development of fossil fuels, including natural gas, irrespective of the costs or the impact on ordinary people.
James Lovelock, who coined the term “Gaia,” notes that the green movement has morphed into “a religion” sometimes marginally tethered to reality. Rather than engage in vigorous debate, they insist that the “science is settled” meaning not only what the challenges are but also the only acceptable solutions to them. There’s about as much openness about goals and methods within the green lobby today as there was questioning the existence of God in Medieval Europe. With the Judeo-Christian and Asian belief systems in decline, particularly among the young, environmentalism offers “science” as the basis of a new theology.
...
They are losing the debate because they have refused to engage skeptics and have instead engaged in name calling such as "denier." If Big Green has become a religion it has also become a doomsday cult pushing a "the end is near" rationale for adopting crushing regulations. It is looking more and more like an excuse for a despotic control freak government.
Comments
Post a Comment