Apartheid was good old days for blacks in Zimbabwe

Nicholas Kristof:

Here’s a measure of how President Robert Mugabe is destroying this once lush nation of Zimbabwe:

In a week of surreptitious reporting here (committing journalism can be a criminal offense in Zimbabwe), ordinary people said time and again that life had been better under the old, racist, white regime of what was then called Rhodesia.

“When the country changed from Rhodesia to Zimbabwe, we were very excited,” one man, Kizita, told me in a village of mud-walled huts near this town in western Zimbabwe. “But we didn’t realize the ones we chased away were better and the ones we put in power would oppress us.”

“It would have been better if whites had continued to rule because the money would have continued to come,” added a neighbor, a 58-year-old farmer named Isaac. “It was better under Rhodesia. Then we could get jobs. Things were cheaper in stores. Now we have no money, no food.”

Over and over, I cringed as I heard Africans wax nostalgic about a nasty, oppressive regime run by a tiny white elite. Black Zimbabweans responded that at least that regime was more competent than today’s nasty, oppressive regime run by the tiny black elite that surrounds Mr. Mugabe.

...

People I talked to were terrified for their personal safety if quoted — much more scared than in the past. That’s why I’m being vague about locations and agreed to omit full names.

But what is clear is that Zimbabwe has come very far downhill over the last few decades (although it has risen a bit since its trough two years ago). An impressive health and education system is in tatters, and life expectancy has tumbled from about 60 years in 1990 to somewhere between 36 and 44, depending on which statistics you believe.

Western countries have made the mistake of focusing their denunciations on the seizures of white farms by Mr. Mugabe’s cronies. That’s tribalism by whites; by far the greatest suffering has been endured by Zimbabwe’s blacks.

In Kizita’s village, for example, I met a 29-year-old woman, seven months pregnant, who had malaria. She and her husband had walked more than four miles to the nearest clinic, where she tested positive for malaria. But the clinic refused to give her some life-saving antimalaria medicine unless she paid $2 — and she had no money at all in her house. So, dizzy and feverish, she stumbled home for another four miles, empty-handed.

...

There is more.

I have not posted much on Zimbabwe lately because not much new is happening there. This story confirms much of what I have already said about the dreadful conditions in Mugabeland. Things are unlikely to change before he dies, since few in Africa have the will to make him give up power in a fair election.

What is somewhat new is that someone from the NY Times got in to do any reporting on the conditions. The last reporter they sent got jailed and Kristof took his family with him and his son accused him of using them as camouflage.

Comments

  1. Suspect you read Dark Star Safari by Paul Theroux at some point. It contemplates the state of the continent from the perspective of overland travel. One of the best books I've read. I lent it to an IT professor who had been a mid-level administrator, with full time limo and driver, in the Mugabe government before pursuing further education in England. He, to say the least, did NOT like the book indicating that the current state of Zimbabwe is actually the work of the British "Sterling" agreement to which the UK failed to adhere. My understanding is that Mugabe's henchmen did not have the administrative moxie necessary to track the farms seized for appropriate recompense allocation. In any event, the professor's mother still lives there. I can't see continuing as a Mugabe apologist when as you say, "the bread basket of Africa," has been destroyed through incompetence, greed and violence. While the plight of the white farmers might be water under the bridge by now, their absence has resulted in the economic collapse and starvation conditions.

    ReplyDelete
  2. One of the most striking things about the discourse on Zimbabwe is the degree to which it is informed by bias and prejudice.

    For example, is it really fair to mantain, as this article does, that it is Mugabe and his henchmen who have ruined the country?

    Try factoring in the economic sanctions and other acts of sabotage by the international community. Would you still arrive at the same conclusions?

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The myth of 'voter suppression'

Kerry's false premise on UN resolution