Telecom patriots deserve Medal of Freedom

Opinion Journal:

The latest Presidential Medals of Freedom will be presented Monday, and the eight on this year's list are all deserving. They include Brian Lamb, the founder of C-Span, and Oscar Elias Biscet, the Cuban human rights activist who won't be able to accept in person because he's in one of Fidel Castro's prisons.

But here are two suggestions for the next list: CEOs Randall L. Stephenson and Ivan Seidenberg, of AT&T and Verizon, respectively. They deserve recognition not so much in their own right but as representatives of the telecom companies that cooperated with the federal government's terrorist surveillance program in the weeks immediately after 9/11.

Changing technology means that the U.S. National Security Agency can no longer monitor terrorist communications merely by pulling microwaves from the air. Our world of packet switching and fiber cable means that the NSA needs access to the telephone company switching networks to track terrorist plans. When President Bush and the Attorney General requested such cooperation in late 2001, the companies responded despite what they must have known was some legal risk if the public's terrorism fears subsided.

...

This is a good idea. It rewards true patriotism and risk taking for American security. It is also a poke in the eye to the terrorist rights crowd that thinks patriotism is making it harder to stop the next terrorist attack. They don't even want the government to be able to collect the dots much less connect them without jumping through hoops that make no sense in a time of war. The award would also shame those in congressional terrorist rights lobby who are working so hard to undermine our efforts to stop the next attack.

Lee Hamilton
makes the case for the telecoms also. "If the local fire company asked for your help putting out a neighbor's blaze, you would not force the firefighters to justify their request. You would just help, right? That's what the phone companies did when the Bush administration asked them in secret for help with wiretaps to target al-Qaida communications into and out of the country." Well said.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Should Republicans go ahead and add Supreme Court Justices to head off Democrats

Is the F-35 obsolete?

Apple's huge investment in US including Texas facility