Obama's incoherence on Yemen al Qaeda

Stephen Hayes:

Dan Pfeiffer, White House Communications Director, took to the official White House blog Wednesday to post a response to critics of Barack Obama and his handling of counterterrorism. Pfeiffer believes that the intelligence failure that led to the failed bombing on Christmas day -- nearly a year into Obama's presidency -- can be blamed on a war launched almost seven years ago in Iraq. The banality of his claim is surpassed only by its absurdity.

What's more interesting is Pfeiffer's claim that his boss has finally refocused U.S. counterterrorism on its proper targets in places like Afghanistan, Somalia and Yemen.

Pfeiffer mentions Yemen twice. That's not a surprise considering the rise to prominence of al Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula (AQAP) and radical cleric Anwar al Awlaki, both based in Yemen. Awlaki, a senior al Qaeda cleric and recruiter, has offered guidance (at least) to Major Nidal Malik Hasan, the Fort Hood shooter, and Omar Farouk Abdulmutallab, the failed Flight 253 bomber. And Abdulmutallab reportedly had extensive training and support from AQAP. As a result, Yemen -- a nation unfamiliar to most Americans -- has been on our front pages and leading our broadcasts in the past few weeks. So Pfeiffer wants everyone to know that Obama, in his "war against al Qaeda," has been busy building "partnerships" to target terrorist safe-havens in, among other places, Yemen.

To coin a phrase: What a difference a year makes.

On January 22, 2009, Obama signed an executive order requiring the closure of the detention facility at Guantanamo Bay within twelve months. To near universal praise, Obama claimed his action would allow America once again to occupy the "moral high ground" and to "restore the standards of due process and the core constitutional values that have made this country great even in the midst of war, even in dealing with terrorism."

On the same day that Obama made his announcement, the State Department website www.America.gov published an interview with US Ambassador to Yemen Stephen Seche. No other country would be as important to closing Guantanamo Bay as Yemen. Some 100 of the 248 detainees there at the end of the Bush administration were Yemenis. And, with only a few exceptions, those that remained at the facility remained there for a reason. They were seasoned jihadists and they were extremely dangerous.

That fact made Seche's comments notable. He said that it was the goal of the new administration to repatriate a "majority" of the Yemenis at Gitmo. And not just send them to their native country to be detained, but so that they could "make a future for themselves here."

...

The statement was shocking. More than a dozen of the Yemenis held at Guantanamo Bay at the time were alleged by the US government to have been personal bodyguards for Osama bin Laden. Many of the other Yemenis at Gitmo had been trained at al Qaeda training camps (74 percent) or stayed at al Qaeda guesthouses (74 percent). Others had been captured fighting Americans or alongside senior al Qaeda figures -- 15 of them captured in raids that netted top al Qaeda operatives Abu Zubaydah and Ramzi Binalshibh. Still others had admitted their terrorist involvement without coercion and in open hearings -- sometimes accompanying their confessions with threats to one day kill again.

And yet the Obama administration believed that a "majority" of these detainees could be freed in Yemen -- a well-known hotbed of al Qaeda activity?

...

Obama's stated policies on Yemen are in conflict and that cannot be blamed on the war in Iraq or on Bush administration policies. It can only be blamed on the incoherence of the Obama administrations Yemen policies. That incoherence is based on a fundamental disregard for the nature of the enemy and the nature of the detainees it wants to release to become al Qaeda's reinforcements in Yemen.