World War II analogies don't work for insurgencies

Nicholas Kristof makes the mistaken comparison today in his column:

...

The Darfur conflict has now lasted longer than World War II, but this year could be a turning point — provided that President Obama shows leadership and that the world backs up the International Criminal Court’s expected arrest warrant for Sudan’s president, Omar Hassan al-Bashir.

...
Liberals were fond of using that analogy for the Iraq war too. It is an inept analogy in both cases. World War II was a major combat operations combat persisting war. By combat persisting I mean both sides stayed in contact with each other until there was a winner.

In an insurgency the insurgents use a raiding strategy where they avoid contact in order to avoid annihilation. Instead they uses carefully plan raids that give them an opportunity to inflict casualties while their main units survive to fight another day. On average insurgencies last for 11 years. Some last much longer. The one in Colombia has lasted about 30 years. The one ending in Sri Lanka lasted 24 years.

As for the rest of his column, I of course would like to see the world do something about Sudan's inept counterinsurgency operation that has descended into genocide. Unfortunately, the UN and most of the do gooders still do not understand the conflict.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The myth of 'voter suppression'

Kerry's false premise on UN resolution