Tuesday, July 15, 2008

Right of self defense returns to the UK

Telegraph:

They will be able to use force against criminals who break into their homes or attack them in the street without worrying that "heat of the moment” misjudgements could see them brought before the courts.

Under new laws police and prosecutors will have to assess a person’s actions based on the person’s situation "as they saw it at the time” even if in hindsight it could be seen as unreasonable.

For example, homeowners would be able stab or shoot a burglar if confronted or tackle them and use force to detain them until police arrive. Muggers could be legally punched and beaten in the street or have their own weapons used against them.

However, attacking a fleeing criminal with a weapon is not permitted nor is lying in wait to ambush them.

The new laws follow a growing public campaign for people to be given the right to defend themselves and their own homes in the wake of a number of high profile cases.

...

Some of those cases have shown up in my UK police idiot watch posts. I think they should also be able to attack a fleeing criminal. This rule is going to cause confusion and will inevitably lead to more goofy results. The Texas castle doctrine is superior in reducing crime.

0 comments: